The Sydney Morning Herald logo
The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14/20Critics' Pick

Bar Carnation

Updated ,first published

Inside Bar Carnation in the former Gerald’s Bar site on Rathdowne Street.
1 / 9Inside Bar Carnation in the former Gerald’s Bar site on Rathdowne Street.Coco and Maximilian
Vitello tonnato is a paragon of the form.
2 / 9Vitello tonnato is a paragon of the form.Simon Schluter
Bar Carnation has taken over the former Gerald's Bar space.
3 / 9Bar Carnation has taken over the former Gerald's Bar space.Simon Schluter
Fritto misto.
4 / 9Fritto misto.Simon Schluter
Daylight helps to soften the minimalist room.
5 / 9Daylight helps to soften the minimalist room.Simon Schluter
Steak frites with sauce diane and house-made fries.
6 / 9Steak frites with sauce diane and house-made fries.Simon Schluter
Mozzarella bolognese: meat sauce and cheese on a thick slice of toast.
7 / 9Mozzarella bolognese: meat sauce and cheese on a thick slice of toast.Simon Schluter
The Gerald’s bar top remains but almost everything else at Bar Carnation is fresh, including slanted ceiling mirrors “for people watching”.
8 / 9The Gerald’s bar top remains but almost everything else at Bar Carnation is fresh, including slanted ceiling mirrors “for people watching”.Coco and Maximilian
The chocolate mousse is darker and more grown-up than many on Melbourne menus.
9 / 9The chocolate mousse is darker and more grown-up than many on Melbourne menus.Simon Schluter
14/20Critics' Pick

Bar Carnation

European$$

The white-walled wine bar filling big shoes on Rathdowne Street.

Talk about a hard act to follow. Gerald’s Bar 1.0 is officially done, but the universe has rebalanced quickly. You could call it a pared-back version of its older sibling Carnation Canteen: the menu shorter and more direct, but written with the same quality of ingredients, seasonings, saucing and composition that won its big sis a fervent fanbase.

Fritto misto uses the best seafood available that day, frying it to light, delicious crispiness. Vitello tonnato is simply a paragon of the form, classic in every way, the veal tender, the sauce tangy and exacting. You’d order the steak frites simply for the diane sauce; imagine the best gravy spiked by acid and mustard and pure deliciousness.

Service is fantastic in that ineffable, laid-back way that mimics a carefree spirit but is actually underpinned by true professionalism. There’s a ripper wine list, too, and the staff will gladly guide you through it while they gauge exactly what kind of night you want to have. Gerald’s has moved on, but this is one worthy successor.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement