The Sydney Morning Herald logo
The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

‘We looked like idiots’: Inside McLaren’s bold strategy gamble and why it failed

Hannah Kennelly
Updated ,first published
Pinned post from 8.32am on May 25, 2026
Go to latest

‘We looked like idiots’: Inside McLaren’s bold strategy gamble

By Hannah Kennelly

Oscar Piastri sounded the alarms early.

Menacing dark storm clouds were hovering over the Circuit Gilles-Villeneuve and McLaren engineers decided to take a gamble. They would give their two drivers – Lando Norris and Piastri starting third and fourth respectively– intermediate tyres in preparation for the wet weather they were certain would come.

Oscar Piastri had to make several pitstops during the Canadian Grand Prix.Getty Images

The McLaren duo were the only drivers in the top 10 to take that risk – the rest of the grid started on softs.

Piastri had his doubts. “I feel like I’m floating,” he warned his engineers over the radio during the three formation laps. The Australian went back and forth with his team, asking if they should switch tyres, but McLaren told him to stay.

It wasn’t necessarily a mistake from McLaren, but a bold strategy gamble that would pay off if it rained.

The race began and the rain never came.

View post on X

Piastri was forced to pit at the end of the first lap for slicks and plummeted down the scoreboard losing places.

His teammate Norris snatched the lead from pole-sitting George Russell after an impressive start. However, Norris was also forced to pit after his tyres failed, losing valuable places and rendering McLaren’s realistic podium dreams completely unreachable.

Then it got worse.

While trying to execute an overtake on Ollie Bearman, Piastri slammed into Alex Albon’s Williams car and copped a 10-second time penalty and wing damage. Norris later suffered a gearbox failure and had to retire.

Both McLaren drivers finished with zero points with a DNF from Norris and an 11th place finish from Piastri.

Piastri spoke with the media after the race and apologised to Albon and Williams for the incident. The Australian also addressed McLaren’s tyre gamble.

View post on X

“ I mean it was raining … unfortunately for us, it stopped raining as the formation lap started, just one of those things where if it rained a little bit more we would have looked like heroes, but it didn’t so we looked like idiots,” he said.

Norris said it was “not our day from a decision point of view”.

“I guess we made the decision as a team, I also pushed for it, so I kind of take the responsibility for that one. But.… I don’t think we had the pace today,” he said.

There was plenty of poor luck and car trouble around the grid, with race-leader George Russell suffering a power unit failure and forcing a retirement. The furious British driver angrily threw his headrest of out his car, and will likely cop a fine from the regulatory body, the FIA.

Race winner Kimi Antonelli. Getty Images

After extraordinarily tense battle, Antonelli capitalised on his teammate’s retirement and snatched the lead, winning the Canadian Grand Prix and extending his championship lead. The Italian teenager has now won four consecutive grands prix and boasts a 43-point lead in the championship.

It was bittersweet news for the Mercedes team who were hoping for a 1-2 finish. The atmosphere in the garage looked fairly tense as both drivers furiously battled it out, with neither willing to give an inch.

Both drivers were told to tidy up their racing before they caused a crash, with the pair nearly colliding during lap 6.

View post on X

Antonelli repeatedly attacked Russell for the lead, complaining at times Russell had “pushed him off”, and the race lead switched numerous times. After Russell’s power failure, Antonelli easily snatched the lead and sailed to victory, with an impressive Lewis Hamilton in second and Max Verstappen in third to complete the podium

Speaking after the race, Antonelli said it was “a fun battle with his teammate”, noting the windy conditions made racing tricker.

“It was a shame for him [Russell] to have the failure as we would have had a close battle, but we will take it. A big thank you to the team,” the Italian said.

The next race will be in Monaco on June 7.

Latest Posts

That’s all folks

By Hannah Kennelly

Phew, what a race!

Thanks so much for joining our coverage of the Canadian Grand Prix. Join us on June 7 for the next race in Monaco.

Have a lovely day.

Pinned post from 8.32am on May 25, 2026

‘We looked like idiots’: Inside McLaren’s bold strategy gamble

By Hannah Kennelly

Oscar Piastri sounded the alarms early.

Menacing dark storm clouds were hovering over the Circuit Gilles-Villeneuve and McLaren engineers decided to take a gamble. They would give their two drivers – Lando Norris and Piastri starting third and fourth respectively– intermediate tyres in preparation for the wet weather they were certain would come.

Oscar Piastri had to make several pitstops during the Canadian Grand Prix.Getty Images

The McLaren duo were the only drivers in the top 10 to take that risk – the rest of the grid started on softs.

Piastri had his doubts. “I feel like I’m floating,” he warned his engineers over the radio during the three formation laps. The Australian went back and forth with his team, asking if they should switch tyres, but McLaren told him to stay.

Canadian GP: The best pics

By
Lewis Hamilton congratulates Kimi Antonelli. Getty Images
This is the Mercedes teenager’s fourth grand prix victory. Getty Images

Podiums for Antonelli and Hamilton. Getty Images
Advertisement

Mercedes teenager wins Canadian Grand Prix

By Hannah Kennelly

Kimi Antonelli has won the Canadian Grand Prix, after an extraordinarily tense battle with his teammate George Russell, extending his championship lead and smashing F1 records.

It was a disastrous day for McLaren with the papaya team taking a gamble and choosing to start both their drivers on intermediate tyres, despite objections from Piastri.

Kimi Antonelli has won the Canadian Grand Prix.Getty Images

Despite starting third and fourth respectively, Norris and Piastri had to pit early to switch tyres, loosing vital places and plummeting down the scoreboard.

Then it got worse.

Hamilton executes brilliant overtake on Verstappen

By Hannah Kennelly

THROUGH GOES HAMILTON!

After patiently waiting, the Ferrari driver has surged and overtaken Max Verstappen to snatch second place.

View post on X

Kimi Antonelli will likely win this race.… unless a mechanical calamity unfolds and will boast a 43-point lead.

10 laps to go

By Hannah Kennelly

The stewards are going to be very busy after this race.

We’ve had numerous infringements, yellow flags, virtual safety cars and penalties, and now we’ve got 10 laps to go.

View post on X

Kimi Antonelli is still our race leader and has a very healthy eight-second margin, with Red Bull’s Max Verstappen in second.

Lewis Hamilton is in third with his teammate Charles Leclerc in fourth. Oscar Piastri is still stuck in 13th after a disastrous day.

Advertisement

Can Hamilton hang on for a podium?

By Hannah Kennelly

Kimi Antonelli has a comfortable eight-second lead over Max Verstappen in second place.

We’ve got Lewis Hamilton in third, can the champion hang on for a podium? Aussie Oscar Piastri is in 13th place with a 10-second time penalty.

‘I’m lost for words’: Devastated Russell speaks

By Hannah Kennelly

A disappointed George Russell said the car suddenly suffered a power unit failure, noting “everything turned off all of a sudden”.

“I’m lost for words,” he said.

Russell said he enjoyed the battle with his teammate, noting “that’s what racing is about”.

Can Piastri salvage his race?

By Hannah Kennelly

We’ve now lost six cars in this race.

Sergio Perez has had trouble with his car and has had to retire. There are only 17 drivers left on track right now.

View post on X

Oscar Piastri is in still in 11th and needs to snatch one more place in order to grab some points.

However, due to his 10-second time penalty, points look unlikely.

Advertisement

Lando Norris out of race; All hope rests on Piastri

By Hannah Kennelly

Yep, it can still get worse for McLaren.

Lando Norris looks like he’s had a gearbox failure and has had to retire. All hopes for points now lie with Oscar Piastri who is in 11th.

He needs to overtake Ollie Bearmann to sneak into the points.

Advertisement