The Sydney Morning Herald logo
The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

As it happened: Nine witnesses set to give evidence on day six of the hearings

Angus Dalton and Alexandra Smith
Updated ,first published

Hearings conclude for the day

By Angus Dalton

Today’s hearings for the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion have ended. They will resume tomorrow at 10am.

Here’s what we covered today:

  • Antisemitism had been rising for a decade before October 7, 2023, most Australians don’t recognise antisemitic tropes, and people are increasingly less willing to have Jewish friends, chief executive of anti-hate organisation The Dor Foundation Tahli Blicblau said.
  • Antisemitic incidents are five times more common now than they were before October 7, according to Julie Nathan, the research director for the Executive Council of Australian Jewry.
  • The mother of a teen subjected to vile Jewish hate comments while gaming online called for better Holocaust education.
  • Joshua Moshe, a target in the 2024 doxxing of a Jewish WhatsApp group, said police didn’t investigate posts attacking him as a Zionist because they weren’t considered antisemitic.
  • Melbourne Rabbi Daniel Rabin said Jews had been asking him whether they should leave Australia. He said: “Don’t be shy. Don’t be scared. Don’t hide from who you are. Be proud as Jews.”
  • Rabbi Menachem Dadon has told the commission his 14-year-old daughter is “strong” after she was shot and injured at the Hanukkah event during the Bondi terror attack.
  • Singer-songwriter Deborah Conway said people had yelled and hissed at her at concerts and writers’ festivals because of her support for Israel, and that she was worried for young Jewish artists.

Deborah Conway says supporting Israel viewed as a ‘crime’

By Angus Dalton

Musician Deborah Conway said she regards anti-Zionism as a “genocidal impulse” and that she had lost several performance bookings because of backlash to her views.

“ I think it’s really important to say that I support Israel’s right to exist. I don’t support all of the Israeli government’s ways of prosecuting the war,” she said. “But, you know, we didn’t ask for America to be dismantled because it prosecuted the war in Afghanistan or Vietnam or Iraq badly … I think that idea of anti-Zionism is, in fact, a genocidal impulse,” she said.

Conway said she released a new album in August but many venues had cancelled her live performances.

“There were … venues that were targeted almost immediately that their advertising went up by pro-Palestinian supporters who made it their business to target those venues and to make sure that they knew that if they went ahead with it, there would be trouble. And so they pulled out,” she said.

Deborah Conway performing with husband Willy Zygier in 2024.

Deborah Conway yelled and hissed at during writers’ festivals

By Angus Dalton

Musician Deborah Conway has spoken of being screamed and hissed at during writers’ festival appearances.

One incident happened while she was on stage at an event in Western Australia, when “all these people rose to their feet within the auditorium and unfurled their signs and started screaming things at me, and I was shocked,” she said.

At another festival, her interviewer pulled out, and “there was one person that hissed at me, ‘shame on you’. And I just thought, wow, you know, [that’s] kind of a very strange thing to find at a writers’ festival in a regional town”.

Advertisement

Deborah Conway said mentions by PM ‘like a doxxing in itself’

By Angus Dalton

Musician Deborah Conway was asked about her involvement in a WhatsApp group of Jewish creatives who were “doxxed” in 2024.

“I guess I’d already doxxed myself. I was an out there Zionist and out there Jew. I hadn’t hidden anything,” she said.

“But ... it was interesting. The Prime Minister mentioned my name several times … perhaps because he was so shocked that someone within the coterie of the arts world that he was aware of, that he knew, that maybe he’d grown up with my music, or whatever, was being subjected to this kind of behaviour,” she said.

Anthony Albanese mentioned Conway several times in condemning the targeting of Jewish artists.

“But that was kind of like a doxxing in itself, because he’d mentioned my name so many times in so many various interviews,” she said.

Deborah Conway recounts learning of Israel attack amid performance

By Angus Dalton

Singer-songwriter Deborah Conway has told the royal commission she was on a Melbourne stage on October 7, 2023, performing with her husband when their daughter in Israel texted them to say she was hiding in a stairwell amid the attack on Israel.

Conway said she reacted with “just horror, just this extraordinary shock to my very core”.

She said the gathering at the Sydney Opera House after the attack “was a wake-up call”.

“The glee, the jubilation, these celebrations, or protests, or whatever you want to call them, that were taking place … I just thought, am I living in 2023 Australia, or is this 1933 Berlin?”

Deborah Conway gives evidence at the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion on Monday.Fairfax Media

Injured girl asked father after Bondi: Why do they want to kill us?

By Angus Dalton

Rabbi Menachem Dadon has told the commission his 14-year-old daughter is “strong” after she was shot and injured at the Hanukkah event during the Bondi terror attack.

He said she cried as she asked him, “Why they hate us so much? Why [do] they want to kill us?”

“We as a society have to think how we came to this place, that [a] father doesn’t have an answer to his daughter.”

Rabbi Menachem Dadon gives evidence at the Royal Commission.Fairfax Media
Advertisement

Rabbi inviting non-Jews to Shabbat to improve cohesion

By Angus Dalton

Rabbi Daniel Rabin from Melbourne’s Caulfield Shule argued Zionism and Judaism couldn’t be separated, and “we wouldn’t be sitting here if this was just about criticism of Israel”.

“If anybody knows anything about Judaism, it’s they’ll see that the land of Israel is so much part of our faith. It’s not just some separate part of our identity. We pray about it. Most of our holidays are revolved around it. So many of our commandments are applicable only in the land of Israel.

“So it’s not just some distant sort of political thing that was created recently … for the majority of the Jewish community that I know, Zionism is who we are.”

He said some had sought to cast Jews as genocide supporters or “baby killers”.

“If you [are] marking an entire community like that, what chance of success is in social cohesion?” he said. “It’s going to require, of course, political leadership, religious leadership, business leadership, the high levels, to call out these lies. But of course, we can’t rely solely on government.”

Rabin said his synagogue had held events such as “Shabbat to Share”, where members were asked to bring a work colleague to have dinner and see the service, to help dispel misconceptions about Jews. “The feedback has been phenomenal,” he said.

Rabbi says Jewish people ask him if they should leave Australia

By Angus Dalton

Rabbi Daniel Rabin from Melbourne’s Caulfield Shule said many members of his community had asked if they should leave Australia, amid rhetoric that he said branded any link to Israel or Zionism as inherently evil.

“I think the biggest shock to me was people asking me, genuinely, should they leave Australia? Is this the writing on the wall?” he told the commission.

Rabbi Daniel Rabin gives evidence at the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion.Fairfax Media

Rabin said it reminded him of stories from Jewish ancestors in pre-Holocaust Europe who asked themselves similar questions. “And of course, we know the outcome. So to hear such questions is very confronting,” he said.

“Look, I’m an optimist by nature ... I’m not telling people they should leave.

Target of abuse told police, eSafety couldn’t investigate

By Angus Dalton

Jewish saxophonist Joshua Moshe is telling the commission about the fallout from the leaking of a WhatsApp group for Jewish creatives he was part of in 2024, which led to the band he’d played with for seven years ejecting him from the group.

After the leak, a caller threatened the homewares shop Moshe ran with his wife in Melbourne, telling the pair to watch their backs, and sent a photo of their son taken from social media.

After reporting posts made about him and his family online to the police, an officer told Moshe they could investigate vandalism of their store and the threat involving his son, but not the other posts targeting Moshe because they didn’t “cross the line” into antisemitism.

Joshua Moshe (left) and wife Maggie May.Justin McManus

“I said, ‘So, how are you defining antisemitism?’ Because, from my perspective, the word ‘Zionist’ or ‘Zio’ is being used here as a proxy, and ... it’s having an effect on Jewish Australians, and this has the potential to get much, much worse from here on out, and it’s having a serious impact on Jewish Australians lives,” he told the commission.

Advertisement

‘Devastating’: Jewish musician speaks on fallout of WhatsApp group leak

By Angus Dalton

Jewish musician Joshua Moshe is speaking about the fallout that followed the leaking of parts of a WhatsApp group for Jewish creatives he was part of. Within hours, people had shared Moshe and his wife’s social media pages and the Instagram page of their North Melbourne homewares store.

“There were images of me taken from my press photos as a musician, saying that I’m a Zionist or a Zio, and that I’ve been plotting for the Zionist entity,” Moshe, who was hit by a surge of abusive messages, said.

“We were receiving emails, we were receiving Google reviews, Facebook messages. It was relentless,” he said.

“It was just an ongoing torrent of messages through all those channels, and I was feeling extremely anxious, devastated, feeling like my life was starting to unravel, not knowing what would happen at the business and where this information would go and who would act on it ... I was fearing for my safety. Yeah, I struggled to sleep. I had elevated heart rate. I had night sweats. This was devastating.”

Maggie May Moshe and Joshua Moshe closed their Thornbury gift shop after being doxxed and threatened by political activists.Justin McManus
Advertisement